Social Security Disability Appeal Lawyer New York

A black icon of a judge’s gavel resting on a sounding block.

 Denied Benefits? You Still Have a Path Forward

If your disability claim was denied, it’s easy to feel stuck or unsure what to do next. You may be asking, “What happens after reconsideration?” or worrying about missing the next step. The Social Security process includes multiple appeal stages, and each one has strict deadlines. At Simon & Gilman LLP, we help clients move forward with a clear plan—so your appeal stays on track.

The Disability Appeals Process Explained

After an initial denial, the process typically follows these steps:

Reconsideration Appeal

A review of your claim by a different examiner.

Hearing Before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) 

A more detailed review where you can present your case.

Appeals Council Review 

If needed, further review of the ALJ’s decision.

Each stage builds on the previous one, making it important to submit complete and accurate information throughout.

How to Request a Hearing With a Judge


If your reconsideration is denied, you can request a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge.


  • The request must generally be filed within 60 days of your reconsideration decision
  • Filing on time keeps your appeal active
  • Missing the deadline may require starting over

Submitting your hearing request correctly helps ensure your case continues without interruption.

Statue of woman holding scales of justice, symbolizing legal services in personal injury & criminal defense.

What Happens at a Disability Hearing?

If you’ve never been through a hearing, it’s normal to feel uncertain.

Hearing Formats

Hearings may take place in person, by phone, or through video.

Who Is Present

An Administrative Law Judge, you (the claimant), and possibly vocational or medical experts.

What Is Reviewed

Your medical records, work history, and how your condition affects your ability to work.

The goal is to create a clear record that supports your claim.

A person in a suit hands a document to another person across a desk with a scale of justice and a judge's gavel.

What Evidence Should You Bring?

Strong documentation is key at the hearing stage.

  • Updated medical records and treatment history
  • Statements from doctors about your limitations
  • Work history and functional limitations
  • Any additional supporting documentation

Organizing evidence properly helps present a complete and consistent case.

Get Help Title Here

Contact Us

Get Help Now!

Can a Lawyer Represent You at the Hearing?

Yes. A lawyer can help:

  • Prepare your case before the hearing
  • Organize and submit evidence
  • Guide you through questions from the judge
  • Ensure procedural requirements are met

Having structured support can make the process more manageable.

Common Questions About Disability Appeals

  • How long do I have to request a hearing?

    You typically have 60 days from the reconsideration decision to request a hearing.

  • What happens after reconsideration?

    If denied, you can request a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge.

  • What evidence is most important?

    Medical documentation that clearly shows your condition and limitations is critical.

  • Can I appeal a denied disability claim?

    Yes. There are multiple appeal stages available through the Social Security system.

Help for Disability Hearings in New York

Working with a Social Security disability appeal lawyer in New York means you can get clear answers and structured guidance. From our office on Queens Boulevard in Elmhurst, Simon & Gilman LLP provides practical support for SSDI hearings and appeals.

Take the Next Step in Your Appeal

If you’re searching for a Social Security disability appeal lawyer in New York or need help preparing for a hearing, Simon & Gilman LLP is ready to assist. Serving our clients since 1978, we help clients navigate the appeals process with clarity and direction. Start with a consultation and keep your claim moving forward.